next up previous
Next: 2. THEORETICAL FITS TO Up: REVIEW OF THE WORKSHOP Previous: REVIEW OF THE WORKSHOP

1. LABORATORY FITS TO ASTRONOMICAL SPECTRA

For the past several decades, laboratory astrophysicists, notably Mayo Greenberg in Leiden, were conducting experiments to obtain infrared spectra of likely interstellar constituents at low temperatures. We noted their work but largely lacked the ability to surmount the atmosphere to obtain the necessary unobstructed spectra that could have been matched to laboratory data.

With ISO, all this has changed. At this meeting we saw beautifully clear spectra of interstellar ices of water vapor H tex2html_wrap_inline84 O, methane CH tex2html_wrap_inline86 , formaldehyde H tex2html_wrap_inline84 CO, carbon monoxide CO, and carbon dioxide CO tex2html_wrap_inline84 , both in the prevalent form tex2html_wrap_inline92 CO tex2html_wrap_inline84 and in its minor isotopic form tex2html_wrap_inline96 CO tex2html_wrap_inline84 . Spectral shapes showed mixtures of these species in both polar and apolar ices -signifying an embedding in a matrix rich, respectively, in H tex2html_wrap_inline84 O or CO tex2html_wrap_inline84 . Pascale Ehrenfreund also pointed out an important missing ingredient. We have not observed significant levels of admixed solid O tex2html_wrap_inline84 in these ices. This is puzzling, as I will note below.

Ices are useful indicators of the temperatures of the star-forming regions in which they are observed. CO and O tex2html_wrap_inline84 ices sublime at an astrophysically significant rate at roughly 20 - 25K. This is appreciably lower than the sublimation temperatures of CO tex2html_wrap_inline84 or H tex2html_wrap_inline84 O, that lie, respectively, in the range of 55 - 80K and 100 - 150K. Chris Wright showed us spectra of several regions containing young stellar objects. In some, CO appeared fully frozen; in others partially frozen with some addition of gas; and finally, in still others, in fully gaseous form.

Molecular ices found on interstellar grains are likely to be deposits formed when stray atoms are frozen out on a grain and then combine to form molecules. Low-temperature laboratory samples of molecules ion-irradiated with 30 to 60 keV argon ions show spectra that significantly differ from spectra of the same substances before irradiation. Giovanni Strazzulla suggested that processing material this way in the laboratory may not only better simulate interstellar cosmic ray irradiation of grain material, but also dissociate deposited materials and allow them to recombine in ways that more accurately reflect the chemical processing that takes place on interstellar grains.

To date, laboratory astrophysicists have largely worked with materials more or less deposited in bulk on cryogenically cooled surfaces. Yet, we know that the diffuse interstellar features originate in grains that might be aggregates of no more than tex2html_wrap_inline112 atoms. In recent years, however, studies of the properties of atoms such as sodium in clusters numbering about a hundred atoms, have revealed new physical characteristics that differ from bulk properties of the same atoms. Surface effects become important, bond angles change. We may, therefore, expect that the spectra of small aggregates of interstellar atoms and molecules might substantially differ from bulk spectra obtained in the laboratory. Though technically difficult, it should be fruitful to investigate laboratory spectra of small aggregates of atoms, molecules, and perhaps admixtures of ions, that are likely to be important interstellar constituents.

While such considerations are important, there is no doubt that even the bulk properties of different minerals catalogued to date already yield striking results. Louis d'Hendecourt showed us a laboratory spectrum of the magnesium rich olivine mineral forsterite from 10 to 40 tex2html_wrap_inline114 m, and its excellent fit to the dust spectrum of comet Hale-Bopp, again illustrating the usefulness of a broad compendium of spectra of widely differing molecular and mineral species. As Jacques Crovisier then added, the superposed 2.7 tex2html_wrap_inline114 m H tex2html_wrap_inline84 O water vapor tex2html_wrap_inline120 bands yield an ortho-para ratio of tex2html_wrap_inline122 for this comet, suggesting equilibration at a temperature of 25K, corresponding to a distance of order 100 AU from the sun.


next up previous
Next: 2. THEORETICAL FITS TO Up: REVIEW OF THE WORKSHOP Previous: REVIEW OF THE WORKSHOP

Martin Harwit